| MAYOR'S CUP | |||||
| CHAMPION | RUNNER-UP | THIRD PLACE | FOURTH PLACE | # TEAMS | |
| 1983 | UNION CITY | WESLEYVILLE | FLAG | 8 | |
| 1984 | WESLEYVILLE | FLAG | UNION CITY | NORTHWESTERN | 8 |
| 1985 | FLAG | HARBORCREEK | MILL VILLAGE | WESLEYVILLE | 11 |
| 1986 | HARBORCREEK | NORTH EAST | WESLEYVILLE | FLAG | 10 |
| 1987 | FLAG | WESLEYVILLE | TITUSVILLE | MILL VILLAGE | 11 |
| 1988 | HARBORCREEK | UNION CITY | WESLEYVILLE | FLB | 11 |
| 1989 | OIL CITY | EDINBORO | UNION CITY | RIPLEY | 14 |
| 1990 | NORTHWESTERN | RIPLEY | UNION CITY | FLAG | 16 |
| 1991 | UNION CITY | LAWRENCE PARK | NORTHWESTERN | FLAG | 16 |
| 1992 | FLAG | UNION CITY | EDINBORO | WATTSBURG | 16 |
| 1993 | UNION CITY | FLAG | LAWRENCE PARK | WESLEYVILLE | 16 |
| 1994 | HARBORCREEK | EDINBORO | UNION CITY | FLAG | 15 |
| 1995 | UNION CITY | EDINBORO | FLAG | WATTSBURG | 16 |
| 1996 | UNION CITY | HARBORCREEK | NORTH EAST | LAWRENCE PARK | 16 |
| 1997 | UNION CITY | MEADVILLE | CORRY | NORTHWESTERN | 16 |
| 1998 | LEBOEUF | HARBORCREEK | MEADVILLE | NORTHWESTERN | 16 |
| 1999 | NORTH EAST | CVC | MYAA-AMERICAN | MEADVILLE | 15 |
| 2000 | MEADVILLE | CVC | MYAA-NATIONAL | NORTH EAST | 16 |
| 2001 | MYAA-AMERICAN | NORTH EAST | FLAG | MYAA-NATIONAL | 13 |
| 2002 | HARBORCREEK | MYAA-NATIONAL | TRI-BORO NORTH | NORTH EAST | 16 |
| 2003 | MYAA-AMERICAN | IROQUOIS | TRI-BORO NORTH | WARREN | 16 |
| 2004 | IROQUOIS | MYAA-AMERICAN | TRI-BORO NORTH | HARBORCREEK | 16 |
| 2005 | IROQUOIS | MYAA-NATIONAL | LEBOEUF | MYAA-AMERICAN | 15 |
| 2006 | MYAA-NATIONAL | MYAA-AMERICAN | TRI-BORO NORTH | IROQUOIS | 16 |
| 2007 | WATTSBURG | FLAG-O | MYAA-AMERICAN | UNION CITY | 16 |